The Abandonment Epidemic: 81% of Shoppers Turn Their Backs on Brands

The symptoms are unmistakable: plummeting retention rates, spiking customer churn, and brand loyalty flatlining across the US. The recent survey What’s Killing Conversions for Enterprise Retailers? by SCAYLE on shopping behavior confirms the diagnosis: a staggering 81% of US shoppers have abandoned a brand in the past year.

In today's retail battleground, the margin for error is microscopic. One sluggish page load, one confusing checkout flow, one delivery delay quickly turns into another lost customer.

The vital question: how do you vaccinate your business against this spreading contagion? The answer lies in understanding why customers are jumping ship – and how a healthy, integrated commerce approach works as preventative medicine.

The customer experience breakdown

The era of unconditional brand loyalty is clinically dead. Today’s shoppers will walk after just one poor experience – no second opinions needed. SCAYLE's research reveals broken shopping journeys as a primary cause of brand abandonment.

According to the survey, one in three shoppers cut ties with brands over frustrating online or in-store experiences, slow deliveries, or missing discounts.

Consumers expect diagnostic precision across every touchpoint – seamless, consistent, and painless. When even one interaction fails, it creates an immunity to your re-engagement efforts that's tough to overcome.

Commerce teams looking to diagnose their own system weak points do well to start with a full tech stack checkup – before symptoms start showing up in churn data.

The best eCommerce platforms treat this condition by connecting all touchpoints through a unified, modular architecture. The result? A commerce experience that flows naturally whether customers browse on mobile, purchase on desktop, or track orders through your app.

Pricing transparency: the heart of customer trust

"We lost them on price" is an incomplete diagnosis. With competitive analysis just a tap away, customers aren't just comparing costs – they're evaluating the entire health of your value proposition. And that evaluation happens under even closer scrutiny in a market rocked by tariff changes and economic uncertainty. Shoppers aren’t just asking if the product is affordable – they’re asking whether it justifies its price at a time when every dollar feels more precarious.

Price outweighs brand for 36% of shoppers – a signal that perceived value now matters more than familiarity. In moments of doubt, it’s not loyalty that decides – it’s clarity. Hidden fees, limited payment options, and convoluted return policies quickly trigger brand abandonment.

But even transparent pricing can’t compensate for disappointing products. Across all age groups, product quality ranks as a leading reason for abandonment – shoppers won’t pay unless the offering lives up to its promise: opaque pricing structures and inconsistent quality cause a severe allergic reaction in today’s buyers.

This isn’t about being the cheapest option – it’s about building pricing transparency and clearly emphasizing value, making shoppers less sensitive to price alone.

A flexible pricing setup helps maintain a consistent value proposition across channels – building the kind of clarity that keeps price-sensitive shoppers from straying.

The silent killer: tech stack fragmentation syndrome

Here’s a common infection pathway: A customer adds items to your mobile app shopping cart only to find them “unavailable” when they switch to desktop. Or their loyalty points mysteriously reset between digital and physical shopping experiences.

The underlying disease? Systems that can’t or won’t talk to each other. When core platforms like your ERP, CRM, PIM, and eCommerce engine operate in isolation, friction builds and customers walk away.

With 60% of shoppers mixing online and in-store interactions, even small disconnects between channels can break the journey. When experiences feel inconsistent, customers don’t wait for explanations – they disengage. While your teams apply band-aid solutions and manual workarounds, your customers simply leave.

A connected architecture that synchronizes systems in real time is essential for delivering seamless experiences across channels. When core platforms – from checkout to inventory to loyalty – share a single source of data, the result is less friction, faster responsiveness, and stronger customer relationships.

The prescription: unified commerce therapy for long-term survival

Cart recovery emails won't heal brand fatigue. Loyalty points can't bandage over broken experiences. And price slashing creates an untenable addiction, not sustainable health.

So the most effective treatment combines both prevention and cure: Building a commerce backbone that's as agile as today's market demands – one that's unified, composable, and designed to evolve with changing conditions.

Ready for a full commerce health check? Learn what else is killing conversions for enterprise retailers – and how to overcome it. SCAYLE surveyed over 1,500 US shoppers about why they abandon brands, and what keeps them coming back for more.